2011-12 Postseason Predictions, Part II: NFC

NFC Postseason

1. Philadelphia Eagles (12-4) – NFC East Champion, Home Field Advantage

Even before I went through and picked winners for all 256 regular season games, my two favorites to represent the NFC in the Super Bowl were Philadelphia and Atlanta, so I was not at all surprised to see them at the top of my postseason preview.

The biggest question for me going into 2011 is how players like Michael Vick and DeSean Jackson respond to the high level of success they had last season (with the bigger concern in my mind being Jackson). As they say, “pride goes before the fall.” Take Chad Ochocinco for example. He got a big head, started showing off, and what has happened? Is he still a very good receiver? Yes, absolutely. But I rarely rank him in my top 20-25 for NFL receivers anymore. Will DeSean Jackson suffer the same fate? I believe the answer to that question is the key to just how close to 12-4 and home field advantage the Eagles will get.

Now, regardless of their offense, the Eagles have a fantastic defense this season that will take them to the playoffs. With the addition of Nnamdi Asomugha to their secondary, complimenting an already solid defensive corps, it will be very difficult for their opponents to establish any kind of passing game, and the ground attack can only take a team so far.

2. Atlanta Falcons (11-5) – NFC South Champion, 1st Round Bye

A big part of this record, in my mind, is how the Falcons will do at home. I have them winning around seven of their home games, meaning they are right around .500 on the road. They had a lot of success at home last season and I think they will continue that this season. Their fans are even more expectant of success this year and will be that much louder, disrupting their visitors.

The key to getting a better record than what I predict (by winning away games) is the development of Matt Ryan. For the past few years I have said that Ryan could develop into a Peyton Manning type quarterback, and I still see that potential. But I did not see much improvement over the course of last season, so the question in my mind is what he has done and how much he has improved over the offseason without the help of coaches keeping track of his work and guiding his progress.

3. Green Bay Packers (10-6) – NFC North Champion

The Packers are the type of team that should be good for many years. If they made the playoffs each of the next ten seasons, I would not be shocked by any means. In the same breath, they are not a team that I see leading the conference during the regular season. To me, they scream, “peak during the postseason!” And in a lot of ways, that is the best way to do it, especially for an NFC team where 10 wins in a season, until last season, virtually guarantee a playoff birth.

Aaron Rodgers plays very well into this style. He plays well throughout the season, but his best games seem to be the last few of the regular season and then his postseason performances.

They will also, again, have one of the toughest defenses in the league, with a secondary that is very difficult to pick apart, a line that is nearly impenetrable with the run, and linebackers who can defend the run and the pass.

They key will be keeping players healthy. Last season they won the Super Bowl with 13 really good players on IR, but do not count on them having the same success if they lose a lot of players to injury again this year.

4. Arizona Cardinals (10-6) – NFC West Champion

The addition of Kevin Kolb makes all the difference to me. The Cardinals are a talented team, and have been for several years now. They had all the necessities for a playoff team, even last year, except for a quarterback who could lead them. With Kurt Warner, they did some things nobody expected from them. Last year, without Warner, they struggled to a 5-11 record, winning just one game against an NFC West opponent.

With a Kolb taking the snaps for them this year, I think we see Arizona back in the postseason and a playoff game in the desert.

5. Tampa Bay Buccaneers (11-5) – 2nd Place NFC South, Wild Card

Tampa Bay could just as easily sneak off with the NFC South title and a 1st round bye in my mind, it is that close. Raheem Morris, in his second year as head coach (he lead Tampa to a 3-13 record in 2009), showed what his work ethic can accomplish, shocking the NFL by taking his team to a 10-6 record, barely missing the postseason (it is not common for 10-6 not to make the playoffs in the NFC). 2nd year quarterback Josh Freeman was great, throwing just 6 INTs to 25 touchdowns (only Tom Brady threw fewer among quarterbacks with at least 450 pass attempts last season).

With LeGarrette Blount and Mike Williams returning, Tampa Bay’s offense is set.

Defense may be Tampa Bay’s weakness, but Morris is a defensive head coach, so any huge issues should be taken care of by the time week 1 of the regular season rolls around.

6. Dallas Cowboys (9-7) – 2nd Place NFC East, Wild Card

Dallas, honestly, does not impress me that much. That said, I think they have the potential to hit 10 or even 11 wins. Why? Jason Garrett. After the team started 1-7 last season, Wade Phillips was fired and Garrett was named the interim head coach. He led the team to a 5-3 finish. With Tony Romo back, I honestly feel like Dallas may be at a disadvantage. If Kitna were the starter, I probably would have given Dallas another win right off the bat.

Romo has had a good deal of success, and he is earned all of it. But during his 5+ games last season, Dallas only delivered one win. Kitna came in and Dallas lost two more game under Phillips and then went 5-3 under Garrett (with those 3 losses being by a combined 7 points). That first loss with Kitna could just as easily be faulted to him needing time to develop a rapport with the offensive starters.

If Romo has bounced back well from his injury and can return to his pre-2010 success, the Cowboys should do fine under one of the best young head coaches in the NFL.

Could Sneak In

New York Giants

Honestly, I do not see the Giants getting into the postseason. I only have them on this list because I have them winning nine games, and one more against a team I did not expect them to win against (maybe the Cowboys) would put them in.

Minnesota Vikings

Leslie Frazier did not have quite the same success following Childress’ firing as Jason Garrett did after Phillips’, but the Vikings have some things going for them. They are rid of Brett Favre, and though he was a good quarterback last year, that is all he was. Gone was the 2009 Brett Favre who miraculously led Minnesota to the NFC Championship game.

Now, they have Donovan McNabb, who could actually do really well since ex-Redskins have generally trended upward after leaving the D.C. area. The Vikings have one of the best defensive lines in the NFC (I only rank Detroit’s above theirs) and their secondary, though not superb, is solid. With Peterson in the backfield and a good corps of receivers, McNabb, if nothing else, should see success closer to what he had in Philadelphia than what he did in Washington.

Detroit Lions

As I mentioned above, the Lions probably have the best defensive line in the NFC, and they make a case for best in the NFL. Ndamukong Suh is a one-man wrecking crew in the trenches, and with the addition of Nick Farley in the 2011 draft, the question will be how running backs can get out any running room and how long will quarterbacks have to go through their progressions and get the ball out of their hands before the pocket collapses on them. Only the best quarterbacks will find any success, and even the best running backs might not find any, against this Lions defense.

My problem is the question mark surrounding the offense. They have a very good wide receiver in Calvin Johnson. But who should be leading the offense? Matthew Stafford or Shaun Hill? And will Jahvid Best stay healthy? He played very well on his injured foot last season, but if he cannot keep that foot in good shape, he can only play on it so long before it starts taking years off his career.

I say it is one more year that Lions fans will have to wait, but they could sneak in this year and I can definitely see them in the postseason following the 2012 season.

Chicago Bears

I do not know about the Bears. They could have another really good season this year and get into the postseason, but I wonder if their run last year, only to fall at the hands of Green Bay, at home, in the NFC Championship game may doom them to a disappointing season this year. Jay Cutler is a good quarterback, and I think if he could have continued last year in that game last year, he would have. When you are sacked 52 times (12 more than the next most sacked QB) in a season, I have difficulty challenging your toughness.

But, until he proves otherwise, I put him in the same category as Rex Grossman. He did a pretty good job last year, but he rode his teammate’s success to a deep playoff run. He was not the reason for them making the postseason, at least not in my mind.

Lovie Smith has been doing a really good job with this team, and he will continue to, but I think it will be another case of a good year followed by a few poor seasons before the next playoff run in Chicago.

New Orleans Saints

Drew Brees has proven that the Saints can never be counted out. I think that with the rise of Tampa Bay as a team to beat in the NFC South, the Saints may be left out of the dance this year.

But you never really know for sure. They still have a very good defense, coached by Gregg Williams, one of the better defensive minds in the league. They also nabbed Mark Ingram Jr., the only Heisman winner in Alabama’s history, late in the 1st round of the 2011 draft. Reggie Bush had a spotty career in New Orleans before leaving for Miami this season, but maybe Ingram will find more success.

All I know is that the Saints will have to prove themselves to me before I consider them a playoff team in 2011.


You can see my complete standings predictions and my AFC Postseason Preview at the following URLs:

Standings: 2011-12 Postseason Predictions, Part I: Standings
AFC Postseason: 2011-12 Postseason Predictions, Part II: AFC